Carnivora is a morphological and ecological diverse clade of mammals with high species richness (>280 species; 4th largest mammalian order), large range of body sizes from the 200 g least weasel to the 4,000 kg southern elephant seal, as well as a diverse range of body shapes from robust bears to streamlined seals and elongate weasels. I found that the diversity of body shapes between carnivoran families was best predicted by clade age but not rates of body shape evolution or species richness. This suggests that older families simply had more evolutionary time to accumulate more diverse body shapes than younger families.
Evolutionary theory would suggest that variation in body shape can arise as adaptations to ecological diversity such as in locomotor modes, hunting behavior, and dietary ecologies. Contrary to what I predicted, I found that adaptive models with different ecological regimes were poor predictors of carnivoran body shape. Instead, the best supported model exhibited clade-based evolutionary shifts, indicating that the complexity and variation of body shape landscape cannot be effectively captured by a priori ecological regimes. That evolutionary shifts in body shape occurred along taxonomically named clade branches is consistent with previous findings that carnivoran families serve as evolutionarily significant units and that disparate evolutionary and ecological processes often drive differences in morphological disparity between individual carnivoran families
However, some ecological influences on body shape evolution cannot be ruled out because the water to land boundary appears to drive opposing body shape allometry in terrestrial and aquatic carnivorans. The mechanical demands of gravity drive negative allometry (smaller species = more elongate bodies) in species with terrestrial ecologies whereas the balance between drag reduction and thermoregulation drives positive allometry (larger species = more elongate bodies) in species with aquatic ecologies. These opposing allometric relationships also highlights the contribution of body size in influencing body shape evolution.
Law CJ. 2021. Evolutionary and morphological patterns underlying carnivoran body shape diversity. Evolution. 75:365-375. doi.org/10.1111/evo.14143
Law CJ. In press. Ecological drivers of carnivoran body shape evolution. The American Naturalist. doi.org/10.1086/715588
Made with Mobirise.com